Our Fault

Content Warning: This section of the guide includes discussion of emotional abuse, sexual content, and graphic violence.

Almost a year after Noah Morgan and Nick Leister break up, Noah can’t keep from crying. She pulls her car over, unable to stop her tears. She knows he’s the one, despite everything that happened between them.

Noah heads to the airport for her flight from LA to New York City for her best friend Jenna Tavish’s wedding. At the gate, her mind drifts into memories. 

The narrative shifts into the past. Nine months prior, Noah learned that Nick was leaving LA for New York. After their breakup, Noah packed her things—leaving her and Nick’s cat N with her mom Raffaella and stepdad William Leister—to start college. She spent months in therapy trying to get over the breakup but knew she had to see Nick before he left. She showed up at his apartment—the apartment they once shared—and begged him to take her back. She apologized for cheating on him with her former therapist Michael O’Neil, but Nick insisted he couldn’t forgive her. He pinned her to the wall and kissed her, insisting that he had loved her, but she hurt him too badly.